Difference between AC and DC Transmission

In this topic, you study the Difference between AC and DC Transmission.

The conventional AC transmission system as

Difference between AC and DC Transmission

The two AC circuits converted for DC transmission are shown below

AC and DC Transmission

Point of Comparison AC Transmission DC Transmission
Economics Costlier

Complicated

High towers

Insulator cost more

Conductor size bigger

Cheaper

Simpler

Low light poles

Lesser

Conductor size lesser

Power loss  More Lesser
Efficiency Efficiency lesser Efficiency more
Skin effect Present Absent
Di-electric loss More Lesser
Corona effect Predominant Less predominant
Cost of compensation More Do not require compensation
Terminal equipment Not much Due to converters, filters, cost increases.
Distances Economical For long Distances Costly  for long distances
Control of power transmitted Less controllability than  In DC Fast controllability due to converter control
Fault current control Control requires time Controlled fastly
Voltage control In AC, it is complicated due to line charging and inductive voltage drop Easy
Change of voltage level Possible due to use of transformer Not that easy
Reliability Good Quiet good

 

Published by

Electrical Workbook

We provide tutoring in Electrical Engineering.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *